As the luxury fashion world evolves with each season, innovation often involves reinterpretation. Prada's Spring/Summer 2025 menswear collection recently ignited a controversy that feels strangely familiar. At first glance, it appeared to be just another high-fashion runway show. But then, the camera panned down, and social media erupted. The reason? Prada had debuted a pair of "heritage-inspired" leather sandals that carried a strange resemblance to Kolhapuri chappals, the same handcrafted, culturally rich footwear worn across rural and urban India for over 800 years.

What truly amplified was not just the striking similarity, but the unreasonable price tag, which is nearly ₹90,000 for a design with such deep-seated Indian roots. This immediately sparked a crucial debate. Is this an act of genuine appreciation, transparent appropriation, or something far more nuanced? This blog aims to understand or decode Prada’s latest move, delving into the complexities of cultural appropriation in the context of high fashion.

To truly grasp the extent of the backlash, one must understand Prada's standing. This is a brand that doesn't merely chase trends; it sets them. Under the creative direction of Miuccia Prada and Raf Simons, the fashion house is renowned for taking practical objects and reinterpreting them with unparalleled high-fashion precision. They have successfully transformed uniforms, workwear, and even sportswear into valuable luxury items.

However, this time, Prada touched something far more sacred than a functional object; they touched upon a profound cultural identity. Kolhapuri chappals aren't just footwear; they are a symbol of heritage, history, and the vibrant tapestry of Indian craftsmanship. They are worn by a diverse range of people, from farmers in Maharashtra to fashionistas in Delhi. They are not rare or exclusive; they are an integral part of everyday life.

This raises a critical ethical dilemma for luxury fashion branding–where do we, as an industry and as consumers, draw the line between "inspiration" and "erasure"? The incident forces a re-evaluation of ethical branding in fashion and the responsibility luxury houses bear when drawing from diverse cultures.

Let's examine the product itself. Prada’s sandal features a T-strap leather design, a flat sole, and hand-stitched detailing, all of which are signature elements of the Kolhapuri chappal, originally crafted in the Kolhapur region of India. The resemblance is undeniable and goes beyond just coincidence.

Crucially, the Kolhapuri design has been protected by Geographical Indication (GI) in India since 2019. This means that its origin, qualities, and reputation are linked to its geographical source, and its craftsmanship is protected by law. The GI tag, administered by the Controller General of Patents, Designs and Trade Marks, helps preserve traditional knowledge, cultural heritage, and the livelihoods of local artisans. For a luxury house to repackage this outline without clearly acknowledging its origins, especially a GI-tagged product, doesn't feel like a respectful nod.

While cross-cultural design and fashion borrowing are not new phenomena, designers routinely draw from cultures worldwide, the core of the outrage isn't about the design itself. It's about the context, or, in this particular case. When traditional crafts, perfected over centuries by specific communities, are repurposed and sold at unreasonable prices by global brands without proper attribution, it fundamentally undermines the original creators and the cultural significance of their work.

The internet, as expected, did not hold back. The moment images of Prada’s sandals surfaced, a wave of luxury brand backlash erupted across social media platforms like Instagram, Reddit, and X.

• Fashion critics quickly labelled it "a textbook case of cultural appropriation."
• Indian creators flooded platforms with side-by-side comparison videos, humorously mocking the price tag of the Prada version versus the affordable, authentic Kolhapuri. Many pointed out that genuine Kolhapuri chappals can be purchased for as little as ₹500.
• Mainstream media, from prominent Indian publications like Vogue India and The Hindu to international outlets, began publishing in-depth think-pieces on what many termed "luxury colonialism."
• Every day, consumers voiced their frustration, expressing a deep sense of outrage.
• Influencers and celebrities also provided their input. Edelweiss Mutual Funds CEO and MD Radhika Gupta emphasised the importance of preserving India's textile heritage, regretting that "Every child knows who Prada and Gucci are, but very few in a room know a Himroo, Sambalpuri or Narayanpet." 

What we are witnessing is not just anger but a profound exhaustion from being copied without being credited, of seeing one's culture become someone else's marketing campaign. It’s a demand for brand authenticity and fair recognition.

For Prada, the short-term media buzz, even when controversial, isn't always negative. Talking about luxury fashion, it often excels in attention. However, the long-term risk is far more significant: losing cultural goodwill and diminishing brand authenticity.

Today's consumers, particularly Gen Z and millennials, are different. They don't just buy products; they invest in values. They expect brands to understand the crucial difference between celebrating and stealing. Data consistently shows that younger demographics prioritise ethical sourcing, transparency, and social responsibility. A 2024 report on luxury consumers highlighted that a remarkable 100% of Gen Z respondents consider luxury items essential because "they are the stuff of dreams," driven by social media and influencers. However, this same demographic is increasingly ready to boycott brands that take a position on societal issues that contradict their beliefs.

This isn't Prada's first time Prada has faced backlash. The brand has faced criticism in the past, including allegations of racially insensitive imagery and a historical lack of diversity in casting. However, this time, the controversy feels deeper. It touches upon an emotional chord, which highlights the ongoing power imbalance in global fashion where designs from the Global South are often re-appropriated by Western brands. In the world of luxury fashion branding, where perception is everything, such controversies can significantly impact a brand's long-term desirability and trust.

Further reports indicate Prada is now engaging in discussions to explore potential collaborations, signalling a move towards more ethical fashion marketing practices. This step, although under pressure, suggests a recognition of the need for genuine collaboration, rather than just appropriation.

Confetti Design Studio's expertise lies in navigating these complex cultural landscapes, advising brands on how to build bridges rather than inadvertently creating divides.

This incident involves a single pair of ₹90,000 sandals. It's a reminder of a systemic issue in how the fashion industry continues to borrow heavily from the Global South, often without acknowledgement, without credit, and without reciprocal benefits. It forces us to ask whether traditional crafts can survive being merely renamed as fleeting "trends" on international runways.

The path forward for luxury brands is clear and demands a fundamental shift in their approach to cross-cultural design:

• Listening and Engaging: Brands must genuinely listen to the communities from which they take inspiration.
• Collaborating Respectfully: Instead of just "taking," brands should explore authentic collaborations. There are some examples where luxury houses like Dior and Louis Vuitton have engaged in more respectful partnerships with Indian artisans, showcasing their craftsmanship with due credit. Dior's Winter 2023 collection, for instance, featured an extensive examination of Indian culture, incorporating traditional embroidery and designs with clear acknowledgement.
• Telling the Full Story: Brands need to narrate the complete story behind the design, crediting the cultural origins and the artisans who have preserved these traditions for centuries. This promotes true heritage branding.
• Uplifting Traditional Crafts: Beyond recognition, there's a responsibility to ensure fair compensation and sustainable practices that directly benefit artisan communities, which means supporting initiatives that protect GI-tagged products and empower local craftspeople.

The best fashion doesn't just inspire; it respects. It's time for brands, no matter how powerful their Prada marketing strategy, to evolve and do better. They must acknowledge that the most powerful thing a brand can do sometimes is to "walk a mile in someone else’s chappals," prioritising genuine ethical fashion marketing and demonstrating true brand authenticity.

Navigating the complexities of cultural sensitivities and building an authentic brand narrative is important in today's global market. As an expert agency that has worked with fashion and lifestyle brands, we understand the nuances of luxury fashion branding and the critical importance of ethical branding in fashion.

Confetti Design Studio is your creative partner, delivering bold branding, eye-catching packaging, smart websites, and marketing that gets you noticed. We specialise in helping brands create compelling stories that resonate with consumers, ensuring their fashion marketing strategies are authentic, respectful, and impactful. Our expertise extends to creating truly responsible and effective campaigns. 

Need help branding your business?

Check out our services to bring your brand to life today!